apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


AT Survey: Mosquito Magnet - Yes or No?

8-17-mosquito.jpgWe've seen these things (Mosquito Magnets) both in use and gathering dust in people's yards this summer, and we've also seen them recommended by Mitchell Owens today in H&H. Now we want to know what you think, so we can put this to rest. While we are always prone to believing in new gadgets, we are skeptical about this one. We need convincing...

 
 

Tags

Surveys

Related Links

Share

Comments (16)

If you just need to get rid of mosquitoes for a party or something, big fans totally work. Mosquitoes are weak pilots. If it's at all windy, they'll leave you alone. Ceiling fans on the back porch are key.

posted by Henry Abbott on 2006-08-18 10:48:53

I don't have any personal experience with mosquito traps but this article from Science Daily reinforces the notion that a mosquito trap alone won't rid you of your mosquito problem.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2005/06/050607013042.htm

As with most home issues prevention is the best bet. Here are some more tips.
http://www.mosquitobuzz.com/control/mosquitoprevention.html

posted by Chuck on 2006-08-17 16:40:52

And I'll tell you why I voted no...

The reason they attract mosquitos in the first place is their production of CO2, which emulates animals exhaling. They do indeed attract mosquitos, and kill them, but they produce CO2, which we should all be cutting back on anyway.

They also tend to attract them from farther away, which doesn't really solve your problem.

Reducing their breeding grounds when possible, encouraging mosquito feeding animals and insects to live in your area, and a few citronellas (which are attractive lights as well) tend to solve most problems... I think so anyway.

posted by kvh on 2006-08-17 17:02:08

Around here (the South), people and businesses are using a derivative of the Chrysanthemum (Pyrethrum) to control mosquitos--it's a mist that gets sprayed twice a day. Patio dining would be impossible without it. one commercial brand/service is http://www.buzzoffmosquito.com

posted by ocgrl on 2006-08-17 17:03:35

My parents had two at their marshy, mosquito-heaven house and they worked really well. Until they stopped working altogether. The company took them back and sent new ones. And they stopped working too. The woman at the UPS store said people had been returning them all summer.

This was last year, so perhaps they have fixed this problem since then. (I just had to hold myself back from saying "perhaps they have worked the bugs out". heh. said it anyway...)

posted by caitlin on 2006-08-17 17:38:10

We live in interior Alaska - mosquito heaven in the summer.If you don't have a mosquito trap in your yard up here, you're simply unable to sit in your backyard. Yes, you get a few bites here and there, but it is much more preferable than being driven mad by insects.

posted by christen on 2006-08-17 18:51:10

Great article in This Old House on this -

http://jcgi.pathfinder.com/toh/print/0,17071,457950,00.html

We definately need one of these -- we have a lovely garden, but the dense vegetation of ours and our neighbours' gardens is prime mosquito territory (especially the cedar hedges).

posted by Monika on 2006-08-17 18:55:59

One of these was "included" with our house when we bought it...we found it completely useless. It just never seemed to work.

posted by missuswayne on 2006-08-17 20:21:30

My girlfriend's parents have one in their back yard and it works wonderfully.

posted by Grady on 2006-08-17 20:36:05

I have one of these in my East Village studio. It is really awesome!


Seriously, isn't this APARTMENTtherapy.com? WTF is this doing here?

posted by BillyBob on 2006-08-17 20:52:28

I live in Alaska, with a plethora of the little devils surrounding my cabin, yet this device only killed 30 or so within two weeks. never bothered to renew the bait after that. Waste of a good propane tank better used on BBQs! Elecrical bug zappers work better, except you need darkness at night, which we're short of in the summer!

posted by Cindy on 2006-08-17 22:25:07

I live in the woods and got one this year. There are NO mosquitoes in my yard. I'm not kidding, I have not seen ANY, and this is a place where you either screen or stay inside.

I have been running it since Memorial Day and replacing the propane and attractant religiously.

Also, they produce a minor amount of CO2. I did some research and found that most reviews say that the amount of CO2 produced isn't enough to have a serious environmental impact, especially in areas where the alternative would be spraying pesticides from the air or ground. Commentators at Treehugger.com and WorldChanging.com say that preventing the spread of diseases like West Nile outweighs the small amount of CO2 production. You could also help minimize the effect of emissions by planting additional trees and plants in your yard (plants absorb CO2).

posted by pete on 2006-08-18 10:10:57

Thanks for the info Pete -

posted by kvh on 2006-08-18 12:11:59

I bought one for my childs preschool and in about 3 weeks all mosquitoes were destroyed, this product really does work well. I am going to use one in my own yard next season and see if it can do a better job that the dragion flies. :)

posted by Home2Garden on 2006-08-20 23:45:26

The traps are fantastic when used and maintained properly. They have certainly made our summers much more enjoyable. We never used to be able to entertain outside after dusk, and now we can pretty much party the night away outside without getting bitten. Plus, it's great to know our dogs aren't at risk either.

posted by Brian on 2006-08-21 10:18:49

I've used one for 2 season now, it works great. Before I installed it we couldn't eat out doors in the eveing. I also recommended one to a friend and he also loves it.

posted by bob on 2006-10-16 15:07:52