apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Trimmed VS Trimless: Electrical

0617_bocci.jpg

The new 22 electrical outlet by Bocci, pictured up top, got us thinking about flush trim and how desireable (and laborious) it is in modern architecture. We know we would love flush trims in our own home; from the base of the wall to the frames on the doors. But we also know that the trim in older spaces was often beautifully embellished and for this we treasure it even today. So, we wanted to round up a comparison between the best of the trimmed and trimless worlds of modern and traditional architecture. Today, we start with electrical trim, from switches to power outlets...

 
 

What's your preference - from an aesthetic or practical point of view - trimmed or trimless?

0617_outlet1a.jpg 0617_outlet1b.jpg

0617_switch1a.jpg 0617_switch1b.jpg

0617_detector1a.jpg 0617_detector1b.jpg

Comments (13)

That Lutron dimmer switch is hardly trimless - all Lutron switches, outlets and control pads use simple screwless trim plates which snap into place and are available in a wide variety of colors and metals.

That said, I'd never specify trimless outlets or flush baseboards - the costs for drywall installation and finishing would easily double and be prone to mistakes (most drywall installers aren't accustomed to the detail and craftsmanship necessary to make this asthetic work) plus you'd never be able to replace a faulty outlet without ripping out the wall.

I'd rather have simple white Lutron switches and outlets, and flat/square edged MDF base trim painted white.

posted by bepsf on 2008-06-17 13:25:03
view bepsf's profile

In each case, the practicality of the trimmed version far outweighs the smooth look of trimless. Think of all the tape you'd use when you repaint the walls. Think of groping for a switch in the dark. Joanne

posted by JoanneM on 2008-06-17 14:32:43
view JoanneM's profile

Leviton's Acenti line is a nice alternative to the Decora style (e.g. Lutron)

Yes, they do fit in standard width electrical boxes, but Leviton recommends the deeper 3.5" type.

posted by cheapo on 2008-06-17 14:37:18
view cheapo's profile

While it aesthetically is pleasing the fact that you have a multitude of steps and no easy way of ever "fixing it." That is a turn off for me.

posted by tashar on 2008-06-17 14:50:34
view tashar's profile

that is the sexiest smoke detector I've ever seen

posted by eowes on 2008-06-17 14:57:23
view eowes's profile

Um, if you want to pass an electrical inspection, you definitely don't want to go with trimless switches or outlets!!

posted by Anna at D16 on 2008-06-17 16:10:35
view Anna at D16's profile

my switch plates are always so dirty from fingers on them/groping for the switch...why would I want that on my wall? and the outlet cover prevents scratches from whatever is being plugged in.

posted by Enamorada on 2008-06-17 16:26:45
view Enamorada's profile

Totally trimless (the upper left) is a downright bad idea. Unless your walls are painted the EXACT same color as the little plugs, they're going to stand out just as much, if not more so. Actually probably more so because we're accustomed to seeing the trim and therefore it doesn't register in our minds. But seeing two round items in the wall of a different color from the wall will just make them "pop out" of the wall.

posted by Daily Nuance on 2008-06-17 16:49:10
view Daily Nuance's profile

Trimless is probably a bad idea, but it does look nice!

posted by charlenemcbride on 2008-06-17 20:24:02
view charlenemcbride's profile

The anthropocentrist in me sees the outlet as a pair of surprised and disappointed smiley faces.

These might be worth the headaches mentioned above if the space is exceedingly minimalist and austere, but otherwise I think the drawbacks outweigh the aesthetic virtues.

That said, I really love that smoke detector!

posted by lightspeed on 2008-06-17 22:00:18
view lightspeed's profile

I have to admit I really love the look of the two round electrical sockets flush with the wall. Seems to me in Europe the "faces" smile, don't they?

posted by kuroneko on 2008-06-17 22:50:11
view kuroneko's profile

One other thought...there should be ultra-thin plates that one can use to "fake" this look. Ideally they would be clear with the option to put wallpaper on the back or paint the back to match the wall. Not a perfect match for the flush look but I'd try it.

posted by kuroneko on 2008-06-17 22:51:17
view kuroneko's profile

If you read the installation instructions for the Bocci trimmless outlet, it doesn't seem that complicated. It uses a regular switch box installation, with a sticker & plate that you mud over. You wouldn't need to tear out the wall to fix anything, just cut out the area around the outlet with a knife, fix, re-mud and paint. Of course this would work best if you have a smooth or a trowelled-on finish so you don't have to match orange peel texture.

Also, electrical inspections are done before the outlets are installed, and a final inspection afterward. Just make sure it works with correct polarity and ground before final inspection. A simple electric plug tester will tell you. Think I'll try it!

posted by lodel on 2008-06-18 01:01:30
view lodel's profile